Amish Country Roll Butter: The Creamiest Kitchen Staple

Amish Country Roll Butter (Salted, 2 lbs) is rich, creamy, and perfect for baking or everyday cooking. Here’s where to buy it and why I keep it stocked.

As an Amazon Associate, Spot The Deal USA may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are subject to change. [Full disclosure here.]

Amish Country Roll Butter: The Creamiest Kitchen Staple

There’s just something extra special about Amish Country Roll Butter. Rich, creamy, lightly salted, and hand-rolled in parchment—it feels like stepping back into a simpler time (but better, because you can grab it on Instacart 🛒).

I picked up the 2 lb roll and honestly? I might never go back to sticks. This butter makes everything—from toast to pie crust—taste like you spent the whole day baking in a farmhouse kitchen.

• Creamy texture that spreads like a dream

• Lightly salted for just the right amount of flavor

• Hand-rolled parchment wrap gives it a rustic, old-fashioned vibe

• Perfect for baking, sautéing, or slathering on warm bread

🛒 Instacart – Just search “Amish Country Roll Butter Salted 2 lbs” and add it to your next grocery delivery. It’s often found in the dairy or specialty section.

➡️Target, of course! You can find these child size shopping carts in store as well.

I keep this butter in the fridge and slice a portion into a butter dish for the counter—it softens just right and makes everyday toast feel like a treat. Also, it looks so pretty in food photos!

• Halloween Dunkaroo Dessert Dip Recipe

• Flamin’ Hot Cheetos Elote Recipe

• Red, White & Blue Summer Salad Recipe

• Pistachio Fluff Dessert Dip Recipe